Lost in New Haven, the local memorabilia museum, celebrated its first anniversary with a stylish gala last Saturday night. The experience suited the nightclub-like space: a live band beneath the Cutler's Record Shop twinkling turntable, cocktails shaken at the first-generation Anchor Spa bar, and long tables dotted with candles alongside displays of The View from the Bottom magazine and vintage glass bottles.
Robert Greenberg, founder and creative director of Lost in New Haven, is not new to club life: before moving back to his hometown of New Haven, he worked as a creative and art director in New York, designing institutions like Club Expo and China Club. Much like those legendary clubs, Lost in New Haven is a multifaceted space, hosting events like The Rocky Horror Picture Show shadowcast showings, a Halloween Eve after hours event, and the inaugural AFTERWORLD winter market. But at Lost in New Haven’s first event celebrating the museum itself, the hosts looked forward to building much more to the museum and corresponding education initiatives.
At first glance, Lost in New Haven looks like a “regular museum:” small exhibits on New Haven’s First Bank and East Rock’s inauguration materials are displayed professionally and somewhat plainly on whitewashed walls.
But just a few rooms in, the museum reveals itself to be anything but traditional. The moody dark walls and seemingly endless exhibits make audiences feel like they’re floating through a New Haven galaxy, bouncing between Lender’s Bagels flotsam and Judges Cave jetsam. There is what feels like an exhibit for everything: local hotels, railroad food menus, barber shops. Not everything here is vintage – modern Olmo bags are set in a New Haven bakery section, and “Elicker for Mayor” signs seem plucked from Orange Street right into the mayoral campaign area.
Greenberg says he was born to do this work. He began collecting at 7 years old when his maternal grandfather Simon Evans made him an ACME toy truck, designed after his family’s business. Greenberg’s paternal grandfather, Joseph, founded the storage and moving company in 1912, after moving to New Haven from Russia.
Evans, an artist and antiques dealer, was inspired to recreate vintage New Haven items after 1960s urban renewal projects destroyed beloved neighborhood institutions, from The Capitol Market to the Monterey Club. Evans would bring the young Greenberg to local festivals, and set up small exhibits commemorating the lost communities. The visitors were part of the exhibit, too, becoming oral historians of New Haven history.
Joseph died before the original ACME building was taken by urban renewal. Greenberg’s father reopened it on Crown Street with a corresponding office furniture business, with pieces that now look straight out of Mad Men. Greenberg would go with his father to demolished factory buildings and salvage the leftover furniture; among the rubble, he would find remnants of humanity lost to the city’s destruction.
Greenberg gathered enough New Haven history to show a collection in his father's ACME building, but said it “didn’t really adapt to the space.” His father ended up selling the building and retiring, so Greenberg moved the collection to a new lease on Grand Avenue. After two and a half years, his landlord sold the building, and Greenberg was evicted again. The collector wouldn’t give up: he tried to show his collection in the former Bopper’s nightclub building on Crown and College, but that did not work out – same with a potential space in Marlin Works, and the Connecticut Savings Bank building.
Finally, in 2020, he found the now permanent spot on Hamilton Street and Chapel Street. “I just gutted the whole building and said, ‘I don't want to leave again.’” He went from 4,000 square feet to now almost 25,000. It may seem like Robert Greenberg has almost everything to make a comprehensive New Haven museum, but the archivist is not done.
The gala is meant to raise money for all aspects of the museum’s growth: “I’m really hoping that people will understand why this is important for future generations. My goal now is to tune up these exhibits and make them immersive,” said Greenberg. “I want to tap your five senses. I put a tire over the Charles Goodyear exhibit so you can smell rubber. I want gravestone rubbing exhibits where you can see textures.”
The museum is constantly getting new pieces; Greenberg regularly visits antique sales, checks eBay, and visits thrift stores to ensure a breadth of New Haven history across all exhibits.
The museum’s team is also growing. Bill Farley is joining the staff as director of education and research after teaching anthropology at Southern Connecticut State University. He is a trained archaeologist, brought on to build out educational experiences for all ages. The museum is currently open only two days a week, so Greenberg leads most tours himself, an arrangement that Farley described as "not scalable."
Michael Morand, New Haven city historian and director of community engagement at the Beinecke Library, recognizes the challenge Robert is taking on in capturing all that makes our city unique:
New Haven has a really, really long history. It's a place that's large enough to be interesting and small enough to be friendly. This crowd tonight shows that: people from all kinds of different backgrounds, all kinds of different neighborhoods, all kinds of different ages, all here because they care about New Haven.
Morand, who is part of Lost in New Haven’s community advisory board, appreciates how the museum has brought people back together who used to be connected by now-defunct parts of the city. The museum seemed indeed nostalgic for many of the attendees, who looked back fondly on the New Haven Ravens days and the Broadway Retail District.
But for many others, this was their first time encountering many New Haven-specific relics. Yale Master of Arts students Bobby Smith and Young Cho were in the space for the first time; their favorite exhibit was Greenberg’s family ACME tool section. They were fascinated by the equipment no longer found in traditional tool kits.
“It's this approximate identification where you can almost clock it, but we're so far removed from the original use of the thing, but we're doing something that's kind of similar to it now,” said Cho. “It’s a very tactile way of looking at history.”
Smith and Cho’s reflection on Greenberg’s raison d’être exhibit seems to be what Greenberg wants everyone to get out of a visit to Lost in New Haven: understand why our city is the way it is through the artifacts themselves. A York Square Cinema sign taken from the university’s destruction of Broadway explains why The Shops at Yale are overrun by corporate shops; a Black Panther zine and poster section explains the Green’s political significance; W.S. Beebe tools explain the New Haven warehouses that surround Lost in New Haven on Hamilton Street.
Modern Western culture desensitizes us to waste, and New Haven is not immune: the State House in rubble below new luxury housing, IKEA furniture laid waste in the rain, trash cans overflowing with pina coladas at Long Wharf. Lost in New Haven asks that we not see these items as discarded remnants, but as historical records. At this museum, that “trash” becomes treasure.